Photo: Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
Sign up for The Gilded Age Club, a subscriber-exclusive newsletter where writers and editors obsess over season four.
This week on The Gilded Age, Elizabeth Kirkland faced her worst fear: a daughter-in-law willing to stand up to her. For two seasons, Phylicia Rashad’s indomitable Newport matriarch has disapproved of almost every aspect of Peggy Scott’s (Denée Benton) life, from her career as a novelist to her past annulled marriage and her father’s status as a formerly enslaved man. But on the eve of Peggy’s wedding to her son Dr. Kirkland (Jordan Donica), Mrs. Kirkland has no choice but to stand down after going too far with her critique of Scott family traditions such as jumping the broom. As Peggy puts it to her future mother-in-law, the choice is Mrs. Kirkland’s: Come to the wedding and put on a happy face, or spend her life “on the outside.” Rashad is heartbreaking in this scene; despite Mrs. Kirkland’s prejudice and sour disposition, she has clearly built her sense of self-worth in a racist society upon her traditional values, and the difficulty she finds in giving them up to appease her son plays painfully across the actress’s face.
Rashad is, like much of The Gilded Age cast, a theater legend, having won her first of two acting Tonys for starring in Lorraine Hansberry’s A Raisin in the Sun in 2004. Rashad is also a director and the former dean of the College of Fine Arts at Howard University, but on The Gilded Age, she’s having a blast playing a woman intensely dedicated to decorum, colorism, and scowls. “I grew up in Houston, Texas,” she says. “Colorism still exists today. I thought, What a wonderful opportunity to explore this mindset, to revel in its ridiculousness, and expose that to people.”
After two seasons of strain, how does Mrs. Kirkland feel about the prospect of Peggy finally joining her family when this episode begins?
Well, there’s not anything she can do about it. She does love her son. She certainly doesn’t want to lose him, and it’s quite obvious to her that that could happen. He is set on this. She’s not been able to persuade him otherwise. And oh, she has tried, but these efforts are to no avail. She has to make a choice and, in order to keep her son, she has to participate in this wedding. But, if there is going to be a wedding in the Kirkland family, it has to be correct and it has to be carried off a certain standard, dear. You don’t just “get married,” and you certainly don’t jump over brooms. She has standards and wants to, I jokingly say, protect the bloodline. It’s serious for her.
The night before the wedding, Peggy tells Mrs. Kirkland that she can come to the celebration or she can be “on the outside,” and Mrs. Kirkland ultimately attends. What do you think that dark night of the soul was like for her?
It’s about her son, because she loves her son. When it comes right down to it, that’s what matters to her. She doesn’t agree with his choice, but she loves him, and she does not want to lose him, and that’s real.
How do you think she raised a son who is so comfortable rebelling against her wishes?
Okay, you’re somebody’s son.
I am.
All right, so you know the answer to that already. You come to a certain stage in development where you want to make your own choices, and if you’ve been reared to address, to expand, and to trust your own intellect, that’s what you want to do. You want to make your own choices. This is not an unintelligent choice, it’s just one that she can’t come to terms with, because it doesn’t conform to what she thought it should and would be. Ideally, she would’ve chosen someone for him, or at least agreed upon it.
What is it that connects her so strongly with this idea of “tradition?”
Here is a group of people who are not necessarily connected to the people from whom they descend, not even aware of what those traditions are and were, not even aware of the wealth of history and learning. For her and people like her, the world is Eurocentric. She’s not crazy — she looks in the mirror. These are the heights to which one must aspire because this is what’s been handed to her. That’s what she’s been taught: “This is culture. This is civilization. This is religion. This is the way a human being should behave.”
Can you imagine a young girl being taught that way by example? There’s also that wonderful, charitable Christian component where you will help the lowly and the people who are not quite on your level. But you don’t marry them.
She specifically says the broom is a “reminder of darkness,” which is such potent phrasing.
Let’s look at slavery. Let’s really look at that, how inhumane that is and how it can render a people. That’s what she is alluding to. She doesn’t want to acknowledge that. “Oh yes, we know it happened, but it didn’t really happen because my great-great-grandfather fought in the Revolutionary War.” Her husband reminds her that, “He played the bugle,” and she says “That counts.”
Audra McDonald’s character, Mrs. Scott, says that Mrs. Kirkland has “forgotten that it’s her history, too.” Is that something Mrs. Kirkland could understand if she heard it?
Oh, no. She would say, “That’s not my history.” That’s how out of touch she is. And maybe not, because not all descendants of Africa in the Western Hemisphere were descendants of enslaved people. That’s another misconception, that all Black people are descendant from slaves. There were free Black people all over the world.
When Mrs. Kirkland ultimately sees the choir and the broom, what does she think?
I think she was surprised at the choir. That was a very pleasant surprise. When that broom came out, she had to breathe and let that little jump happen.
You worked as a dean at Howard University. Do you see The Gilded Age as part of teaching?
In theater, we’re looking at humanity — I say theater because all television doesn’t try to do it, I’ll put it that way. In theater, you’re always examining the human being, the psyche. From the Greeks into now, those great playwrights are writing about the human being. And The Gilded Age is certainly beautiful in this way. Look at the panorama of humanity in The Gilded Age. Look where Bertha really came from and where she sits today. Look at all this stuff she went through with Mrs. Fish, trying to be acceptable, trying to be on the top of society. You see that human beings are looking for the same thing in different ways.
How did you first get involved with The Gilded Age?
My involvement began with the wish of my now deceased manager, Barbra Korn. She had a way of choosing things that were so unique and so fine, and, during season one, she said, “You must see this show. I want you to be on this show.” I was like, “Yeah, Barbra, okay.” Then came a time when her wish came true, and a script was sent to us. By this time, I was aware of the fact that The Gilded Age was a very unique television program in that the entire cast was theater royalty. I had friends who were in it: Audra McDonald and John Douglas Thompson.
What initially grabbed you about Mrs. Kirkland?
Her mindset was not unknown to me. I grew up in Houston, Texas. Colorism still exists today. I thought, What a wonderful opportunity to explore this mindset and to revel in its ridiculousness and expose that to people. It’s not something that we see often, written so well. Elizabeth Kirkland is a human being and, like a lot of human beings who are misinformed, she believes in the information that she has. That’s interesting to me as an actor.
Last season, both Denée and Audra told me that season three felt like a shift in the energy of the show largely because of the entrance of the Kirklands’ world. What was that season like for you?
You could feel it. It was palpable. All of a sudden, my phone was ringing off the hook. Friends who hadn’t watched the show before were watching it. I have one friend who follows the conversation on social media. I said to her, “I know you are a very busy woman. I know you have things to do.” But she said, “But let me tell you what was said today! I’m trying to save Claire Huxtable. The people are outraged!”
What do you think it was about season three that so captured people’s minds?
Audiences love romance and they like to root for romance and long to see it portrayed so honestly in historical context, with so much detail invested in presenting history authentically. There is not a zipper to be had on any of the costumes.
Does that affect your performance?
It supports it for sure. If you’ve ever doubted it, try putting on one of those corsets and see how it makes you sit and stand and walk and feel.
When I talked to Audra, she said sparring with you was difficult because “Phylicia is my Phylicia.” What’s it like for you?
That is my Audra, and I love my Audra, and I love my Denée! It was sport for me. When I look at it at a deeper level, if I wanted to get philosophical and theological about it, look at love. If we are all one at the core of things, that’s love, and yet we’re tangling and pulling apart and fighting each other. For what reason? Because of appearance. Isn’t the state of humanity today refusing to recognize our shared humanity? And look at the pain it causes. But see, this is the good stuff for drama.
Who do you draw on when you’re portraying Mrs. Kirkland’s snootiness?
I have known people who carry themselves in that way. I had a dean of girls in high school, Mrs. Cunningham. Oh, she was quite something. She could have come right out of The Gilded Age, the way she dressed and carried herself, and the way she spoke. She told us one day with great pride, “My husband has never seen me in the nude.”
She told that to a group of girls?
She was talking to us about being discreet. She wouldn’t let us wear sandals to school. She said, on the PA system one morning, and I am not exaggerating, “Now, girls, you mustn’t wear sandals. Your toes excite the boys.” She wore dresses that were almost to her ankles and when she sat down on the stage in the auditorium for assembly, she took a handkerchief, unfolded it, and placed it on her knees.
How would you like to see Mrs. Kirkland grow moving forward?
She has to admit things. She has to come to some understandings that are going to trouble her waters and shake her foundations. It’s very difficult. We see this play out every single day when people are challenged to expand their thinking, to expand awareness and understanding, to move past the concepts with which they’ve been living all their lives. Is this not the great human struggle? And it’s not easy to do. This is what I love about literature and art and theater, because they challenge and afford us an opportunity to expand.
We mostly see the Kirkland parents talking about their son. Have you talked with Brian Stokes Mitchell about what their conversations are like off-screen?
Darling, we have fun conversations. One time he said to me, “Elizabeth, if you don’t stop it, I’m going to spank you.” And I looked at him and I said, “Do you promise?” [Laughs.] We have so much fun.